In plain English
The applicant wants to modify a previously approved plan by adding a second story to the existing forward garage wing and expanding the one car garage. Staff notes several possible issues with the Architectural Design Standards including the wing extending forward, massing concerns, blank walls, and roof shapes. Staff suggests adding more windows on the north side and questions the proposed shed roof on the garage addition.
Why it matters: This affects the homeowner and neighbors by changing how the house looks from the street.
Places mentioned: 43 Wellgate Dr
Original agenda text
43 Wellgate Dr
Addition (1 Car Garage and Storage)
Submitted by Bridget Tipton
a) Staff notes this application received review and approval at the June 24, 2026 AHBR meeting.
b) Staff notes the applicant is requesting a modification of the approved plans including a 2nd story addition to the existing forward garage wing and 1-car garage expansion.
c) Section IV-4 (h)(1) of the Architectural Design Standards states that an additional wing may be added to any mass of the building. This wing must be attached at the rear or side of the building and may not extend forward of the main body. Additionally, Section IV-4 (b)(2) of the Architectural Design Standards states that the front face of the main body must sit forward at least 18” from the front face of the wings. Staff notes the existing house has a forward 1 story garage wing; however, the 2nd story addition would substantially expand it.
d) Section IV-4 (b)(1) of the Architectural Design Standards states that wings may not be larger or taller than the main body of the structure, but they may be the same height. Staff recommends the Board consider whether the proposed 2nd story addition would create a massing concern. Staff notes the proposed 2nd story expansion would further emphasize the existing atypical forward wing.
e) Section III-1(g)(8) of the Architectural Design Standards state that large expanses of blank wall are to be avoided. Fenestration placement should be at a maximum of approximately every 12 feet. Suggest additional fenestration on north side elevation to better meet this requirement.
f) Section IV-4 (c) of the Architectural Design Standards states that all roofs in all the wings must be of the same shape as the main body, but they may have a different pitch or orientation. Roofs shall not intersect a wall so as to cause a valley. Question the proposed shed roof garage addition, as the main mass has a hip roof.
Exactly as published by Hudson · File AHBR 26- 209 · AHBR Application · Agenda item 13.
Official agenda (PDF) City meeting page
Explain it in more detail
Get a deeper walk-through: what this item does, who it affects, what the jargon means, and questions you could ask at the meeting.
Nov 18, 2026 Architectural & Historic Board of Review
The board will discuss replacing a historic clay tile roof with asphalt shingles at 190 N Main Street in the Historic District. The application was continued from the October 28 2026 meeting. No new information has been provided...
historic preservation
Nov 18, 2026 Architectural & Historic Board of Review
The board will discuss replacing the roof at 186 N Main Street in the Historic District. The existing roof has asphalt shingles but is near historic tile roofs. The application was continued from the October 28 2026 meeting with...
historic preservation
Nov 18, 2026 Architectural & Historic Board of Review
The applicant proposes a roof replacement in the historic district. Staff recommends approval as submitted.
historic preservation
Nov 18, 2026 Architectural & Historic Board of Review
This is a request to replace the exterior door at a house in the historic district. The application was continued from an earlier meeting. Staff notes that the proposed aluminum clad wood door with simulated divided lites would...
historic preservation